Jeremy Plonk (Keeneland / Horse Player NOW)
Owner of Horse Player NOW, a horseplayer education site, and one of Keeneland's four expert handicappers.
Our rating in one line: As of 4 Nov 2026, Jeremy Plonk (Keeneland / Horse Player NOW) has no Performance score yet (insufficient data): keeneland publishes each day's top-three picks (archived by date) but no running record of wins or $2 returns. Transparency score: 25/100 (low transparency).
- Channel
- Racing & sports media
- Outlet / platform
- Keeneland.com
- Type
- Racing media handicapper
- Country
- US
- Coverage
- US thoroughbred racing
- Price
- Free with the outlet; no paid tipping service found
- Audience
- 302 followers on X (@JeremyPlonk), 17 Oct 2026
- Record
- None found
- First seen
- Not found yet
At a glance
- ROI
- Unknown
- Settled bets
- Unknown
- Period
- Unknown
- Evidence
- None
18+. We are not paid by tipsters listed here.
Performance breakdown
Keeneland publishes each day's top-three picks (archived by date) but no running record of wins or $2 returns.
| Published record | |
|---|---|
| Settled bets / selections | Unknown |
| Profit / loss | Unknown |
| Level stakes | Unknown |
| ROI | Unknown |
| Odds basis | US pari-mutuel (tote) payoffs |
| Period | Unknown |
| Basis of record | Unknown |
| Notes | Unknown |
| Source | https://www.keeneland.com/consensus/consensus.php?race_date=10%2F16%2F2026 · checked 17 Oct 2026 |
| Sample size and uncertainty | |
|---|---|
| Settled bets in the record | None published |
| Approximate 95% range for ROI | Not shown (the record is too small or incomplete to score) |
| Re-check cadence | Every 7 days; next re-check due 11 Nov 2026. |
The range is our own calculation from the published record, not the tipster's figure. Winners are paid at different prices, so the true range is at least this wide. How we calculate it.
50 = break-even. Past results don't predict future returns. How we score Performance.
Transparency score breakdown
Daily picks are published about 48 hours before each race and archived by date on Keeneland's Handicappers' Consensus page, but results are not tallied.
| Criterion | Max | Status | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tips published before the off, timestamped | 25 | ✓ Verified | 25 |
| Full record including losers (public ledger or independent tally) | 25 | Not yet verified | 0 |
| Price basis stated (SP, BSP, advised odds) | 15 | Not yet verified | 0 |
| 500+ settled selections | 15 | Not yet verified | 0 |
| Approach and staking explained | 10 | Not yet verified | 0 |
| Results downloadable (CSV/API) | 10 | ✗ Not met | 0 |
| Total | 100 | 25 |
Transparency score: how openly a tool or tipster publishes a record you can verify. How we score Transparency · How to raise a transparency score.
Sources
Is this you? Are you Jeremy Plonk (Keeneland / Horse Player NOW)?
If anything on this page is wrong or out of date, or you can share a fuller or newer record, a results page or your methodology, send us the public evidence. We review every request against our published criteria and log every change on the changelog. Ratings can't be paid for and are never influenced by affiliate status.
How to raise your transparency score · the same checklist for everyone
Embed this badge
Free for this listing. It shows the current rating and check date, updates when they change, and links back here. About the badge · Badge terms
Other horse racing tipsters we rate
- UNDERDOG Racing TipsPerformance 92 · Transparency 80
- The Profit RocketPerformance 85 · Transparency 80
- TheBankerPerformance 85 · Transparency 80
- Value Bet +Performance 83 · Transparency 80
- LIVE FOR RACINGPerformance 80 · Transparency 80
- The Dark HorsePerformance 77 · Transparency 80
Guides: Best horse racing tipsters (UK & Ireland) · Does AI sports betting work? · All guides
How we check records: The transparency checklist (what counts as evidence) · AI tipping transparency report 2026 (how many records pass)